| Getting your Trinity Audio player ready... |

Introduction: Norms as Invisible Governors of Life
In everyday discourse, freedom is often framed as an individual possession: a matter of choice, autonomy, or willpower. If I am free to choose, to speak, to act without coercion, then I am free. But this picture is profoundly misleading. In a very real sense, it makes no sense to think of people as detached from the world they live in, or of the world as an external stage upon which autonomous individuals merely act. Human beings are always already embedded in a lifeworld—a world shaped by material conditions, cultural practices, institutions, histories, and norms that pre-exist us and silently organise our possibilities.
This article explores what I will call the tyranny of normativity: the ways in which social norms, cultural discourses, and structural features of the lifeworld constrain freedom and undermine wellbeing, often without overt coercion. Drawing on enactivism, the Skilled Intentionality Framework (SIF), and a range of philosophical and social theories, I argue that wellbeing is not primarily an inner psychological state but an emergent property of person–world relations. When the lifeworld is inclusive, pluralistic, and responsive to human diversity, it supports agency and flourishing. When it is rigid, exclusionary, or absolutist, it quietly becomes tyrannical.
The Lifeworld as a Human Construction
Canadian philosopher Ian Hacking suggests we understand the world on two levels: the natural world that existed before us, and the human world that has been constructed through countless generations of human activity. Bridges, clocks, computers, legal systems, and social categories did not simply appear; they evolved through historical processes of social construction. Once in place, however, these constructions come to feel inevitable and natural.
Consider our experience of time. The segmented, quantified clock time that governs modern life—dividing existence into seconds, minutes, hours, days, and years—is not a universal human given. It is a cultural artefact rooted in the Babylonian number system invented around four thousand years ago. Cognitive scientist Chris Sinha’s work with the Amondawa people of the Brazilian Amazon demonstrates this vividly. With only four number terms and no abstract numerical calendar, the Amondawa do not experience time as an abstract, linear commodity. Concepts like “wasting time” or “saving time”, so central to Western life, are simply absent.
Yet in industrialised societies, clock time structures education, work, productivity, and even moral worth. Punctuality becomes a virtue; lateness a vice. What appears as a neutral fact of reality is, in truth, a deeply normative cultural framework that disciplines bodies and lives. This is a recurring theme: social constructions become naturalised, and once naturalised, they acquire normative force.
Enactivism: Normativity as Lived Relation
Enactivism provides a powerful lens through which to understand this process. At its core, enactivism rejects the idea that cognition happens inside the head. Cognition is not representation but sense-making: an activity of embodied agents actively engaged with their environments. Living systems are inherently normative—they distinguish what is good or bad for them, what sustains or threatens their continued existence.
Human normativity, however, extends far beyond biology. Through language, culture, and institutions, we inhabit environments saturated with expectations about how to act, feel, desire, and belong. Importantly, these norms are not merely external rules imposed upon passive subjects. We enact them through our participation. But this does not mean we are free in any simple sense. We are born into a world whose norms were shaped long before us, and these norms structure what is intelligible, acceptable, and possible.
From an enactivist perspective, suffering often arises not from internal deficits but from breakdowns in the relational dynamics between agents and their worlds. When the lifeworld persistently fails to support meaningful engagement, wellbeing deteriorates.
The Skilled Intentionality Framework: Fields of Affordances
The Skilled Intentionality Framework (SIF) deepens this relational view by focusing on affordances: possibilities for action that arise in the relation between an agent’s skills and their environment. We are always selectively responsive to a field of affordances, some of which solicit our attention more strongly than others.
Crucially, affordances are normative. A job application, a social cue, or a moral demand does not merely exist; it calls for a certain kind of response. Skilled agents are those who can flexibly and adequately respond to these solicitations. Wellbeing, on this account, involves being attuned to a rich and supportive field of affordances.
Normative tyranny emerges when fields of affordances become narrowed or distorted. When social norms rigidly define what counts as success, normality, or value, the environment repeatedly solicits actions that many people cannot perform or do not endorse. The result is chronic misattunement: a lived sense that one cannot act well or belong meaningfully in the world as it is structured.
Freedom, Rights, and the Conditions of Agency
This brings us to freedom. A crucial distinction can be drawn between experiential freedom—the lived sense of being able to act meaningfully—and political freedom, safeguarded by civil rights and legal protections. Drawing on Amartya Sen’s capability approach, we can distinguish between our doings (skills and abilities) and our beings—states such as being able to live in peace, to love freely, or to enjoy material security.
These “beings” are not internal traits but situational features of the lifeworld. They describe conditions that support or undermine agency. Civil rights matter because they attempt to secure these conditions. But rights alone are insufficient. Human beings also have a deep need for belonging, validation, and acceptance—needs that exist in tension with our equally fundamental need for individuation and self-expression.
Inclusion, Belonging, and Normative Pressure
Marilyn Brewer’s optimal distinctiveness theory captures this tension well. We seek inclusion in groups, but we also want our uniqueness to be valued. Lynn Shore and colleagues’ inclusion framework shows how this balance can fail in different ways: exclusion, assimilation, or differentiation. Assimilation, in particular, reveals normativity’s subtle tyranny. One may belong, but only at the cost of concealing aspects of oneself that deviate from group norms.
Here, norms do not merely constrain behaviour; they shape identity. People learn which parts of themselves are welcome and which must be hidden. Over time, this can erode authenticity, agency, and wellbeing.
Cultural differences further complicate this picture. Geert Hofstede’s cultural dimensions illustrate how norms vary across societies—around individualism, power distance, uncertainty tolerance, or indulgence. None of these differences are inherently problematic. The problem arises when one cultural configuration is treated as superior or universal, and others are pathologised.
Normalising Norms and Symbolic Violence
Michel Foucault’s analysis of normalising norms offers a deeper explanation of how this happens. With the rise of statistics, demography, and epidemiology, human populations became measurable. Regularities were identified, elevated into norms, and deviations pathologised. The “normal” became not just descriptive but prescriptive.
Discipline operates not only through external punishment but through internalised self-surveillance. We learn to police ourselves, to feel shame or inadequacy when we fall short. Social norms thus become naturalised and appear self-evidently legitimate.
Sally Haslanger extends this analysis by linking normality to theological ideas of the natural and the good. What is normal is seen as natural, and therefore morally right; what deviates is unnatural and bad. This logic has historically underpinned the demonisation of homosexuality, disability, and other forms of difference.
Pierre Bourdieu’s concept of symbolic violence captures how these processes operate at the level of everyday life. When one group’s habitus—their embodied ways of speaking, acting, and valuing—is treated as superior, others are implicitly devalued. This devaluation limits access to opportunities and corrodes self-worth. Imposter syndrome, in this light, is not merely a personal pathology but a socially induced experience of misrecognition.
Monotheism, Absolutism, and the Erasure of Plurality
At a more fundamental cultural level, Richard Rorty argues that monotheistic worldviews tend towards absolutism. One God, one Truth, one Way. Deviation becomes error; difference becomes threat. This structure is not confined to religion. It appears in nationalism, ideological politics, and even some forms of scientism.
By contrast, polytheistic or pluralistic worldviews recognise multiplicity. Different gods, different perspectives, different ways of making sense of the world. No single viewpoint exhausts reality. This pluralism mirrors the enactivist insight that meaning is enacted from multiple embodied perspectives.
Normative tyranny thrives under monotheistic logic. When one way of life is elevated as the only legitimate one, exclusion and punishment follow. Wellbeing suffers not because diversity exists, but because it is denied.
Embodiment and the Subtle Policing of Possibility
Normativity operates not only through ideas but through bodies. Iris Marion Young’s phenomenology of feminine body comportment shows how social discourses about modesty and propriety become sedimented in bodily habits. Girls learn to restrict their movements, to take up less space. No explicit prohibition is required. The lifeworld itself trains bodies to move in constrained ways.
From an enactive-SIF perspective, this is a restriction of affordances at the level of embodiment. Certain movements no longer solicit action. Freedom is curtailed not by force but by habituation.
Structural Constraints and the Erosion of Wellbeing
Beyond cultural norms, material and structural features of the lifeworld also shape wellbeing. Poverty is perhaps the most glaring example. It restricts access to education, health, housing, and social participation. It generates shame, hopelessness, and exclusion. Poverty is not merely a lack of income but a corrosive lived experience that narrows the field of affordances.
Policy decisions—cuts to education, precarious labour markets, punitive welfare systems—further constrain life opportunities. From an enactivist perspective, these are not abstract economic issues but concrete modifications of the lifeworld that undermine agency.
Conclusion: Reclaiming the Lifeworld
The tyranny of normativity does not usually announce itself as tyranny. It operates quietly, through what is taken for granted, through the narrowing of possibilities, through the subtle policing of difference. Enactivism and the Skilled Intentionality Framework help us see that wellbeing and freedom are not properties of isolated individuals but achievements of supportive lifeworlds.
The lifeworld can exclude, marginalise, and oppress—but it can also include, sustain, and enable. The ethical and political task is not simply to fix individuals so they better conform to existing norms, but to reconfigure the lifeworld so that a wider range of human lives can flourish.
Wellbeing, in this sense, is not something we possess. It is something we enact together, in worlds that can either welcome us—or quietly, tyrannically, deny us the space to live well.
Discover more from Richard Askew | Actualise Psychotherapeutic Counselling
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

